From steaks to pancakes, griddle and skillet are two of the most important cooking tools in the kitchen. Most people, however, are easily confused between the two. To know more about their differences, read this quick comparison of griddle vs skillet. We’ll also list down some of the top products that should be on your list!
- Top 10 Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens 2021
- America’s Test Kitchen Best Cookware Sets of 2021
- Best Pellet Grill [Smoker] Under $500
- Best Wood Pellet Grill 2021
- Best Built-in Gas Grill 2021
- 1 A Quick Comparison of Griddle vs Skillet
- 2 America’s Test Kitchen Best Griddle and Skillet Reviews 2021
- 3 How to Choose Griddle and Skillet
A Quick Comparison of Griddle vs Skillet
Undecided whether you should choose a griddle or a skillet? It is important that you are familiar with the key similarities and differences to help you choose. Below are some things you need to know:
- Appearance: A skillet looks very much like a frying pan. It is usually round with a flat bottom and shallow sides. A griddle, on the other hand, is usually rectangular with more generous cooking space compared to a skillet. It also has lower walls.
- Application: If you are frying small meals such as egg, then skillets are nice. It is also good for cooking juicy steaks and stir-frying veggies. You can also use it for broiling, sautéing, roasting, and braising because it has walls. It is typically used for slow cooking methods. A griddle, on the other hand, is used mostly for grilling steaks. It is also good for pancakes and eggs. It is common in quick cooking applications, especially when high heat is required.
- Size: If you are looking for something more compact, then you should go for a skillet. It is often round, which makes the surface area smaller. A griddle is larger, which also means that it has a bigger cooking surface. The traditional rectangular shape allows it to hold more food compared to the capacity of a skillet.
America’s Test Kitchen Best Griddle and Skillet Reviews 2021
Looking for a griddle and skillet to buy? Below are some of the top products that should be on your list.
Lodge 15-inch Cast Iron Skillet
The brand name alone is more than enough compelling reason to choose this skillet! Since it is made by Lodge, the durability is unquestionable. It is easy to be a gourmet chef in the kitchen with this skillet! From searing to broiling, this is a multifunctional product!
When you receive the skillet, it is naturally pre-seasoned, which means that it is ready to be used right out of the box. The natural and easy-release finish gets better through time. This also improves the skillet’s heat retention and distribution. There will be no burnt spots on your food!
More so, we love how it can be used in multiple ways. Whether it is on the stove, oven, or grill, the skillet works!
For heavy lifting, no need to worry! There is a long traditional handle on one side and a smaller assist handle on the other.
Le Creuset Cerise Enameled Cast Iron Skillet
The price of this skillet can instantly drive many people away, but that should not be the case. It is from one of the most reputable brands in the market and it has top-notch quality, so it is worth every dollar!
One thing that we love the most in this skillet is its enameled cast iron construction. This is a long-lasting material that also delivers excellent heat retention and distribution. Plus, the surface is already pre-seasoned, so it is ready to use. The enamel coating is impressive as it resists external damages, including stains and cracks.
Even the interior of the skillet has a black satin enamel coating. This is responsible for resisting extreme heat, minimizing the possibility of damage. It can handle temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
Le Creuset Caribbean Enameled Cast Iron Signature Skillet
This is another expensive product that can provide exceptional value for the money! With its heavy-weight construction, durability is second to none. However, this also means that you have to exert a bit more effort when handling the pan.
From the interior to the exterior, it comes with top-notch enamel coating. The latter is the one responsible for promoting even heat distribution while also resisting external damages. Even through the years, you can expect this skillet to be highly functional.
There are two handles – one large and one small. This makes it easy to ensure balance when holding the skillet. Even when wearing mitts, holding the skillet is easy.
With the way it is constructed, it can promote healthier cooking. The surface requires minimal oil, making it perfect for low-fat food.
Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle
The non-stick cooking surface of this griddle is one of its best assets. This way, you can cook with no or minimal oil, which is also a good thing for those who are health-conscious. Plus, it prevents food from sticking, which will make the clean-up a breeze.
Speaking of cleaning, the grill is completely submersible in water. However, before you do so, make sure that you remove the heating element.
We love how it provides complete control when cooking. It is easy to change the heat level depending on what you require.
In terms of construction, we love how its base is made of heavy-cast aluminum. This is a warp-resistant material, making it long-lasting.
Lastly, this griddle comes with a total cooking area of 231 square inches. This makes sure that you have more than enough space for cooking!
Presto 16-inch Electric Skillet and 22-inch Electric Griddle
Can’t decide if you should get a skillet or a griddle? Why not have the best of both worlds? This product from Presto is the perfect alternative as it comes with both. The best thing is that they are both electric!
From roasting to grilling, the 16-inch skillet is beneficial in more ways than one. It has a ceramic non-stick coating, which simplifies cooking and cleaning. The tempered glass cover is also a good thing, which makes it easy to monitor cooking without removing the lid. Plus, it is designed with double handles, which will also make it functional as a serving tray.
Meanwhile, for the 22-inch griddle, a special textured surface is also made of non-stick ceramic. It is extra-large and has removable handles. The latter is a good thing in terms of space-efficiency, making it easy to store the griddle even in compact spaces.
Belovedkai Electric Countertop Griddle
This electric griddle makes cooking a lot easier! You can easily whip up a delicious meal for family and friends. It has 1,500 watts, which means that there is a high output power. You don’t have to wait long before you are done cooking!
It has an intelligent design that allows it to deliver both form and function. One thing that we love is the splash plate, which you can find at the side and back of the grill. This will prevent grease from splattering.
The adjustable temperature is also a plus. This gives you the freedom to change the heat as needed. There is a conveniently located knob, which will allow you to set the temperature from 122 to 572 degrees Fahrenheit.
How to Choose Griddle and Skillet
Whether you are buying a griddle or skillet, it is crucial to be armed with the right knowledge. To help you narrow down the possibilities, below are some of the most important considerations.
This is important as it dictates the overall quality of both the griddle and skillet, including its durability, heating efficiency, and price.
Skillets are made of a variety of materials, including cast iron, stainless steel, aluminum, and copper. On the other hand, in the case of griddles, most of them are made of cast iron. The latter is one of the most preferred materials because of its longevity, as well as excellent heat retention and distribution.
Aside from the main material, you also have to consider the coating used. Enamel is one of the most common. It is known for providing excellent shield from external damages, which can prolong the functional life of both griddles and skillets.
There is no right or wrong when it comes to the size of the griddle and skillet. This will depend on your needs, including space availability in the kitchen and the number of people you are often cooking for. If you often cook for a big family, then you will need a larger griddle and skillet.
This is an important factor if you are buying an electric griddle or skillet. The control is often in the form of a knob, which you can turn to choose the right temperature. This lets you easily customize the heat level depending on what a specific recipe requires.
It is common for a griddle to have two small handles on both sides. For a skillet, on the other hand, the handle is often on one side, which is long, similar to what you will find in a frying pan. In some models, there is also a smaller handle on the other side, making it easy to hold the skillet even when it is full and heavy.
Care and Maintenance
It is frustrating if the griddle and the skillet will require too much effort on your end. Cleaning them should be straightforward. This is why we recommend one that comes with a non-stick coating. This prevents food and residues from sticking on the surface. Pick one that is effortless to maintain in its peak condition even after several years of use.
How to Clean Le Creuset Grill Pans and Skillets